How To Maximize Your Online Community Engagement



Listen to this Article

  • 00:00 | 00:00
  • Has your online community gotten stagnant? Get expert solutions to reinvigorate your member conversations and increase high-quality engagement.

    “We’re just not getting good engagement. We’re not seeing the depth from responses anymore. We’re hearing similar things from project to project.” If you’ve found yourself saying one or more of these things about your online community, you’re not alone.

    An online community is a long-term commitment for everyone involved, and sometimes, conversations with members may start to feel monotonous.

    The root of this problem is typically one of two things:

    • Members don’t feel valued and therefore don’t want to participate;
    • Or members get bored when the research questions and activities become repetitive.

    The problem: Your online community lacks engagement or depth

    Many of our clients have had experiences with communities ― some DIY, some full-service, and some that more closely resemble “panels” with a large sample and no member-to-member interaction ― and have often run into issues with getting (and keeping) community members engaged.

    Do you have an issue with member engagement? Ask yourself:

    • Are members contributing to the community in both incentivized and unincentivized ways?
    • Are member contributions thoughtful and creative?

    Keeping members engaged is essential to conducting research quickly and getting the in-depth answers you need to solve urgent business problems.

    Solution: Make your community members feel valued

    This is true of all qualitative market research; in order for consumers to open up and engage, there needs to be a value exchange that is greater than, “You answer questions, we give you money!”

    Put yourself in their shoes and think about your own experiences. Aren’t you more willing to participate in something (particularly over the long term) if you feel valued for your contributions?

    Here are a few ways to tackle this:

    • Make them feel important – Help members build a feeling of investment in a brand by highlighting the seat you’re giving them at the table and why they got that seat.
      When community members recognize that their unique perspective is valued, they become more thoughtful and don’t hold back from providing hard truths (e.g., the customer critiques that will improve your product or service).
    • Show the impact – Show the members of your community how they have influenced important decisions for the brand. This impact makes members feel like their voices truly matter, which inspires them to “work hard” in every community activity we throw at them. There’s no better feeling than being able to say, “I helped with the development of that ad, product, or service.”
    • Express gratitude – Our moderators know how to “be human.” Responding to research questions in a void doesn’t feel good. Showing gratitude by remembering members’ personal contributions or sharing encouraging feedback helps members feel their moderators truly appreciate what they have to say.
    • Ask follow-up questions – If your respondents are providing short or incomplete responses, asking follow-up questions can help keep the conversation going and get to the insights you’re looking for. This helps set expectations and show community members who may be new to this process the best way they can contribute.

    The problem: You only use the community for one methodology, and it’s gone stale

    When we find a solution that works for our needs (particularly in qualitative market research) we tend to love it to death. As the old saying goes, “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it,” right?


    Over time, even tried-and-true methodologies tend to go stale, especially when you’re partnering with the same community members over the span of weeks or months.

    If you’ve seen a decline in your community’s participation and you’ve made efforts to show members that they’re valued, their work is important, and that they’re having real impact, then you may need to make some bigger changes.

    The solution: Introduce a variety of business problems for community members to weigh in on

    Quite simply, doing the same types of activities in a community over and over gets boring for members. It’s important to think of different ways to capture necessary information.

    • Alternate methodologies – If you’ve conducted five surveys in a row that are all asking the same types of questions, consider introducing a different approach or methodology.Try a card sort, or an in-depth-interview, or even a self-guided ethnography. Variation will help keep members engaged and allow you to flex different muscles in their brains — a tactic that might actually lead to stronger insights.
    • Ask creative questions – If you’re stuck with a certain methodology — say a survey concept test — think of ways to ask things more creatively. If you ask the same questions in every survey, you’ll start to get the same answers from members.Projective techniques and other less direct questions not only yield deeper insights, but they also make research feel less “research-y” and more enjoyable for members.
    • Health checks – We run quarterly health checks on all of our communities — a quick 5-10 question survey that is aimed at understanding what our members are enjoying and what they’d like to see more.This allows us to get ahead of any drops in engagement, because we’re matching the research we need to conduct to the methodologies in which members express an interest.

    Because online communities are nimble, effective, and accessible market research tools, it can be easy to go on autopilot and assume the community will maintain itself; but like any qualitative research program, it’s important to be considerate of the needs of your respondents and foster a community that members want to return to, time and time again.